One of the
recurring problems in both business and government is the absence of reliable
information which unfortunately is shown too late. When decision-makers lack
accurate data, mistakes become more frequent and the resulting costs are often
transferred to shareholders, taxpayers, or the wider public. This is something
that became too obvious during the last two weeks..
While still at
school, I was fortunate to observe the stock markets closely and saw how some
companies strengthened through disciplined management and well-designed
expansion while others declined because of internal rivalry, lack of proper
strategy and goals, poor decisions and weak governance. A few years later, I
noticed the similar patterns in the public administration, both in Cyprus and
Greece. France and the UK were later observed closely, allowing me to
understand that the pattern is common and the only difference it’s the
timeframe of the revelation.
In several
countries, including Cyprus, Greece, Ireland and Iceland (the second pillar of
instability – the first one was USA and the UK, during 2007/8), financial and
governance challenges emerged with different outcomes, especially in Iceland. I
can notice too often the exact same question appearing “ WHY did Iceland was a
more successful model than Cyprus and Greece? “. In my view, the key
distinction was often the quality of leadership, institutional accountability,
and the willingness of public officials to address problems when they became
apparent. Especially for the EU of the last fifteen years and for the UK, it’s
too obvious at moment that the cost of the 2007/8 and the complete mis-management became today unmanageable.
Growing up, around
thirty years earlier, I observed what I perceived as increasing instability in
Cyprus and became interested in understanding its causes. Concerns regarding
governance, public accountability, financial mismanagement and the use of
public resources appeared repeatedly in public debate. At that period, the
pattern looked to my inexperienced eyes as a Ponzi scheme. As I gained more
experience, the pattern took the term PONZI finance, used often by the late
academic Hyman Minsky.
Same remains
the observation for the UK , at moment, as this same is finalized.
Over time, I
connected these concerns to wider problems within the stock market, banking
sector and cooperative financial structures, all of which experienced
significant difficulties. As I continued my research, I sought to document
specific milestones and compare them against broader patterns of financial
instability. This process eventually led me to London, where I focused on
gathering the evidence of mismanagement, testing assumptions and verifying
whether the developments I had observed reflected isolated failures or part of
a larger systemic pattern. Northern Rock, RBS and the EU as an institution,
were all analysed closely under the principle of “too big to fail” and the opposite
one “too big to be saved”.
Today, I
believe similar warning signs can be observed in most of the Western economies,
including the United Kingdom, France and Germany. Rising public debt,
increasing pressure on taxpayers and growing dependence on borrowing raise
important questions about long-term sustainability of each country separately
and the EU as a common union. My concern is that these trends resemble patterns
that have preceded periods of instability elsewhere. I remain extremely sceptical
about proposals for an updated, deeper integration of the UK with the EU
institutions because, in my assessment, significant structural challenges
remain unresolved. The EU is today counting on the funds of France and Germany
which the local populations could not afford for long and the people of the UK
definitely don’t wish to support.
That observation
brings us to the inevitable scenario of “too big to be saved”. Whether political leaders remain in office or
are replaced (especially in the UK where, in the last ten to fifteen years, they
obviously lack understanding the needs and concerns of each area of the country),
I believe the more important issue is whether governments can restore public
trust, improve accountability and demonstrate that current economic models are
sustainable over the long term, when their leaders are far away from reality.
For the moment, I am not optimistic at all..
Based on the
current trend, unfortunately I can observe that both the big EU member-countries
and the EU lack of proper leadership and management, which will makes the on-going
situation even worse. As the UK prime-minister believes that the return to the
EU is a solution for the UK (an illusion bringing back in mind the illusions of
the Liz Truss administration..), my only concern is WHO will pay the cost of a “too
big to be saved” PONZI scheme, the EU is today, since France, Germany and the
UK definitely cannot afford it..